Rajan Agarwal |
Some literary sources have praised a conqueror while others have tagged him as an invader. There has been an inherent bias among historians too which has corrupted the interpretation of history. Some texts were written to the praise of rulers and accorded them godly status while others criticised even their humane acts. Is a one sided approach or a balanced approach justified or are we still far from the truth. History without archaeological or literary evidence is termed mythological or fictional but stories arise from everyday happenings and an element of truth, be it of any minuscule proportion, must have been there.
The rapid advances in science and technology such as remote sensing and satellite technology, along with new findings from sonar readings and carbon dating of submerged underwater man-made sites have helped us immensely in recreating and studying history and full use should be made of it. The worst part about all this research and new discoveries is that these changes are not reflected in the textbooks and students keep reading about things they did 20-25 years ago. One might argue what difference would it make if we come to know that people of Indus valley were ruled by merchants or by priests, whether they cultivated xyz crops, whether Ashoka was as noble as projected or whether Vedic age preceded Harappan civilisation? These questions are mired in debates which have remained inconclusive mostly.
One
must not forget the time period and people under whom our history was penned
down. It was during the colonial era that excavations took place and different
interpretations were given to suit their own needs. It was during this time
that two extreme views were put forward by the colonial historians and
nationalist historians. The essence of the debate was who was superior and it
defeated the purpose of historiography. It is this debate which has continued
till date.
The
colonial historiography of India was based on the pre-conceptions and debates
about the orient in the then European society. This resulted in the creation of
the ‘stereotype’ of the Indian society which was the ‘other’ to the European
society. With the maxim ‘knowledge is power’ in mind, the history of India was
being shaped in a way, so as to help in legitimising the European control over
the sub-continent. The Aryan invasion was indeed a masterly stroke on the part
of the British: thanks to the Aryan theory, they showed on the one hand that Indian
civilisation was not that ancient and that it was posterior to the cultures which
influenced the western world - Mesopotamia, Sumeria, or Babylon - and on the
other hand, that whatever good things India had developed - Sanskrit,
literature, or even its architecture, had been influenced by the West. Thus,
Sanskrit, instead of being the mother of all Indo-European languages, became
just a branch of their huge family; thus, the religion of Zarathustra is said
to have influenced Hinduism - as these Aryan tribes were believed to have
transited through numerous countries, Persia being one, before reaching India -
and not vice versa. The dating of the Vedas and the wrong interpretation of the
caste system and its gradual degeneration to suit vested interests are other
issues to be looked into.
The Nationalist school of historians emerged towards the end of the 19th century. Their interpretation was used for the anti-colonial movement for independence. In this school, history was used for two purposes, firstly, to establish the identity of Indians and secondly by establishing the superiority of the past over the present. For the first purpose, the Aryan theory of race and other similar concepts came handy, whereas for the second purpose, the concept of the ‘golden era of the Hindu civilisation’ was created. This was done because the remoteness in history of the ‘golden age’ was directly proportional to its utility in imaginative reconstructions and inversely proportional to factual scrutiny. The basic thing to be noted is that, the colonial nationalists to a large extent used the same methods of historiography as the imperialists but they interpreted these ‘facts’ differently so as to suit their socio-political needs.
The speed of the attempted textbook revision had been so fast that the newly reconstituted NCERT evidently had some difficulty in finding historians to do this task who would be both reasonably distinguished and adequately compliant. In the early school textbooks that emanated from the NCERT, there was not only the predictable sectarian bias in the direction of the politics of `Hindutva', but also numerous factual mistakes of a fairly straightforward kind. School children were to be taught, in one of the textbooks, that Madagascar was `an island in the Arabian sea and that Lancashire had been `a fast-growing industrial town'.Quite predictably, leftists in India raised a cry of tampering with history, as if history is a fixed science that cannot be adjusted.Former Union minister Shashi Tharoor has apparently come out in support of BJP minister Dr Harsh Vardhan's claim that Greeks and Arabs received credit for advances in Mathematics that rightfully belong to India. He goes on to state that Indian mathematicians invented negative numbers: the British mathematician Lancelot Hogben, grudgingly acknowledging this, suggested ungraciously that "perhaps because the Hindus were in debt more often than not, it occurred to them that it would also be useful to have a number which represent the amount of money one owes".
The time has come for rewriting ancient Indian
History! Are we indeed afraid of the truth so much that we have so forth not
incorporated the recent excavation in standard textbooks? With time new schools
of thought has emerged-the Marxist and the Subaltern which has given a more
holistic interpretation of the events and forces us in the direction of
rewriting ancient Indian history. What is holding us back? Are we afraid what
we have known for years as truth and supported our claims will change? Are we
afraid we will have to face questions for which we will have no answer?
Students have the right to know about the real facts of historical events which
could be corroborated with proofs and sugar coated events tend to make the
subject more like a fairy tale. Debatable portions of history have been termed
mythological and no significant efforts are being undertaken to undertake
further research.
This
attempt at rewriting history is of course meeting with a lot of resistance on
the part of those who have a vested interest in keeping Indian history under
wraps, as well as those who for decades have taught and written books and
articles which blindly copied the British version. But nevertheless, unless it
is done truthfully, however painful it could be for certain sections of India’s
vast ethnic and religious mosaic, India will never be able to face squarely its
own history and evolve a justified pride in its great and ancient civilisation.
------------------------------------------------
Rajan has a keen interest in history.He inspects the recent furore over 'real' history.
Rajan has a keen interest in history.He inspects the recent furore over 'real' history.
a great essay. rajan sir seems to possess lots of knowledge on history. being a beginner i have learned a lot from this essay.
ReplyDeleteI agree with most of what you said but there is no single truth to hunt for. The diversity of opinion is the life-breath of history. Enjoyed your article and Hogben's quote was very amusing!
ReplyDeleteReally this is very great information sharing with us. Thanks lot.
ReplyDeleteExamhelpline.in
Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in ISE 12th Result So
ReplyDeleteThank you for the useful information. You might be interested in Assam Inter 1st Year Result So
Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in AP Inter 2nd Year Results So
Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in Assam Inter 1st Year Result So
Thank you for the useful information. You might be interested in Assam Inter 2nd Year Result So
wonderful details and good site.thank you for sharing with us..
ReplyDeleteSBI PO Admit Card 2017
KSP KSRP Answer Key 2017
BCI AIBE Answer Key 2017
Odisha SSC CPSE Pre Exam Answer Key 2017
AIIMS PG Result 2017
JIPMER MBBS Result 2017
A wonderful post and good site.thank you...
ReplyDeleteOAVS Result 2017
MP Vyapam SOE Answer Key 2017
GPSC Assistant Professor Answer Key 2017
MP Vyapam SOM Answer Key 2017
JEE Main 2017 Answer Key
JEE Main 2017 Answer Key
Thanks..Sharing with us great information.Thanks...
ReplyDeleteJEE Main Result 2017
AIIMS PG Admit Card 2017 for July Session
KIITEE Result 2017
APGENCO AE Admit Card 2017
How to download NEET Admit card on 15th April
Morning Detox Tea for Better health and Glowing Skin
really amazing information given to us..thank a lot
ReplyDeleteTNPSC Jailor Result 2017
MP PAT Admit Card 2017
GSEB HTAT Admit Card 2017
MESCOM Assistant Engineer Result 2017
AP EAMCET Answer Key 2017
CGBSE 10th result 2017
CG Board 12th Supplementary Result 2017
Flipkart deal of the day offers
ReplyDeleteFlipkart discounts on Laptops
Thanks for this wonderful post. Keep blogging.
ReplyDeleteIf you want embarrassing truth or dare questions click link below.
Embarrassing Truth or Dare Questions
Connect with The Most Trusted BULKSMS Provider in India. Attractive Price with Guarantee 100% Delivery. Call: 9907922122
ReplyDeleteBulk SMS service simply means sending out a large number of SMS for delivery to targeted mobile numbers.
Thanks for providing such a nice information. this post is really helpful. It takes strengths to build for the future.. it was really nice that you decided to share this information.How To Trade On Roblox Definite Guide
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your thoughts. I truly appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further post thank you once again. Nice article and pleasant arguments commented here, I am genuinely enjoying by these. New Xbox App for PC
ReplyDeleteThe best information about Indian history, I like this. that article has a top Indian historical fact. I read it they have mentioned the whole India history.
ReplyDeleteGermany VPS Server Hosting